The short answer
Choose a portable power station if you want electricity right away, with no wiring, for weekends, a car or use away from the vehicle. Choose a fixed installation if you live in the van, if your daily needs exceed about 1 kWh or if you want to be able to expand the system later.
Both are valid. The difference has less to do with technology than with how you use the vehicle: occasionally or every day, and how much you like to tinker.
What each of the two solutions is
A portable station combines in one case a battery, a 230 V inverter, a solar controller and USB and 12 V sockets. You connect it to panels or to the mains, and use it immediately.
A fixed installation separates these elements: a battery, a charge controller for the panels, possibly an inverter, fuses, a battery isolator and cables. Each part can be chosen, replaced and added to independently, but the whole must be wired correctly.
Comparison criteria
The table compares the two approaches on criteria you can check yourself on the datasheets. It stays general: the detail depends on the models.
| Criterion | Portable station | Fixed installation |
|---|---|---|
| Getting started | Immediate, no tools | Needs wiring, fuses, often a professional |
| Moving it | Comes out of the vehicle, also useful at home | Stays in the vehicle |
| Expansion | Limited: expansion possible only on some models | Batteries and panels can be added within the limits of the controller and the battery |
| Maintenance and repair | A single block: often a return to the manufacturer | Each part is replaced separately |
| Integration | Bulky in a small space | Fits into unused spaces |
| Risk of error | Lower: the whole is designed to work together | Higher: cross-section, fuse and compatibility to check |
Weight and energy: datasheet figures
As well as the battery, a station carries an inverter and a controller, which increases the weight for the same energy. A battery alone is lighter, but you must add the rest.
The table uses the manufacturers' datasheets. The Wh per kg ratio is a simple calculation (energy divided by weight); it says nothing about lifespan or quality.
| Product (manufacturer datasheet) | Capacity | Weight | Wh per kg (calculated) | What it includes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EcoFlow Delta 2 station | 1,024 Wh | 12 kg | about 85 | battery, 230 V (1,800 W), solar controller up to 500 W |
| Bluetti AC180 station | 1,152 Wh | 16 kg | about 72 | battery, 230 V (1,800 W), solar controller up to 500 W |
| Bluetti AC200L station | 2,048 Wh | 28.3 kg | about 72 | battery, 230 V (2,400 W), solar controller up to 1,200 W |
| Victron Smart 12.8 V 100 Ah battery | 1,280 Wh | 14 kg | about 91 | battery only, no inverter or controller |
| LiTime 12 V 100 Ah battery | 1,280 Wh | 9.53 kg | about 134 | battery only with built-in BMS |
What they power, according to the datasheet
A station like the Delta 2 states 1,800 W at 230 V and a 12.6 V, 10 A output, or about 126 W: enough for a compressor fridge, a router and chargers. The smaller Bluetti EB3A states 268 Wh and 600 W: sufficient for recharging devices, not for a fridge all day.
These figures show the main trade-off: capacity in watt-hours determines how long you last, power in watts determines what you can plug in at the same time. A fridge using 300 Wh per day (an example from our sizing guide) drains a 1,024 Wh station in a little over three days without sun, in theory and without counting losses.
On the charging side, look at the maximum solar power accepted: 200 W for the EB3A, 500 W for the Delta 2 and the AC180, 1,200 W for the AC200L according to their datasheets. This limits how many panels are useful. In winter, the real limit is often sunshine, not this ceiling: see our guide on solar in winter.
Three use cases
To fix ideas, here are three typical situations and the solution that generally suits them. They are guidelines, not rules.
- Weekends and holidays by car or in a small van: a station with one or two folding panels, connected when you are stopped. No installation, and the station is also useful at home or at the campsite.
- A converted van used all year round: a fixed battery of 1 to 2.5 kWh, a controller, panels on the roof and a charger from the engine. The installation lasts, can be expanded and is repaired part by part.
- Mixed use: a station as the main battery, recharged by panels and by the mains socket, with a charger from the engine if the model allows it. Check on the datasheet that a car input exists: some models only have mains or solar charging.
The trap to avoid: mixing without checking
Connecting a station to the van's 12 V installation, or panels to a battery without a controller, exposes you to overcurrents. Victron expressly advises against connecting a panel directly to a battery. Read the manual of each appliance and respect the maximum voltages and currents stated.
The high currents of lithium batteries, and the 230 V of an inverter, justify having any fixed installation checked by a professional. This guide does not guarantee the compliance of any installation. For the general framework, read our guide on regulations and electrical safety.
How to decide
Ask yourself three questions (the thresholds given are simple guidelines, not rules). How many watt-hours do you use per day: below about 500 Wh, a station is often enough; above 1 kWh, a fixed installation becomes more logical. Will you use the system away from the vehicle: if so, the station has an advantage. Are you ready to do the wiring or pay someone to do it: if not, the station avoids the problem.
First calculate your needs with our autonomy calculator. The figures in this guide are from manufacturers' datasheets; compare prices and upgrade options at the time of purchase, as they change.
Sources
- EcoFlow, Delta 2 datasheet
- Bluetti, AC180 datasheet
- Bluetti, AC200L datasheet
- Bluetti, EB3A datasheet
- Victron Energy, 12.8 V Smart lithium batteries
- LiTime, 12 V 100 Ah Group 24 battery datasheet
- Victron Energy, Wiring Unlimited: DC wiring
Safety. This guide is for information only and replaces neither the manufacturer's instructions nor a professional's advice. For 230 V, high currents and any fixed installation, call a qualified professional.