The two families in two sentences
The AGM battery is a sealed lead-acid battery that has long been used in motorhomes. The LiFePO4 (lithium iron phosphate) battery is newer, lighter and copes better with deep discharges.
Usable capacity: the point that changes everything
A 100 Ah battery does not give you 100 Ah of usable energy. According to Victron, a 200 Ah lead battery offers only about 100 Ah in prolonged cyclic use, because you avoid draining it beyond half to avoid wearing it out. A lithium battery can be discharged to 80% or more, depending on its manufacturer.
Victron’s example: a 24 V, 180 Ah lithium battery provides about 3.8 kWh usable at 80%; two 12 V, 220 Ah AGM batteries in series store about 5.3 kWh but give only around 2.6 kWh at 50%.
Comparison table
The figures are orders of magnitude drawn from different sources. Lifespans vary greatly with depth of discharge, temperature and battery quality: always compare the test conditions stated by the manufacturer.
| Criterion | AGM (lead) | LiFePO4 |
|---|---|---|
| Usable capacity | around 50% (Victron) | 80% or more, depending on the manufacturer |
| Weight | clearly heavier (around 2 to 4 times for the same usable energy, depending on the source) | lighter |
| Cycle life | from a few hundred to just over a thousand, depending on the source and depth of discharge | several thousand, according to manufacturers |
| Charging efficiency | around 80 to 85% (non-manufacturer sources) | around 95 to 98% (same sources) |
| Charging speed | slows sharply at the end of charge (Victron) | accepts higher currents |
| Cold | loses capacity | charging is often blocked by the protection system (BMS) below roughly 0 to 5 °C, depending on the model |
| Purchase price | lower | higher |
Cold: a real point to watch
A LiFePO4 battery generally does not charge at sub-zero temperatures: manufacturers include a protection system (BMS) that cuts off charging, and sometimes built-in heating. If you sleep in a van in winter, check this feature on the data sheet.
Compatibility with your installation
The charge controller, the charger and the inverter must all support the chosen chemistry: charging voltages are not the same. A lithium battery needs a BMS (protective electronics) and, according to Victron, a fuse with a sufficient breaking capacity. A lithium battery with no clear marking or data sheet from an identifiable manufacturer is best avoided.
So, which one?
There is no single answer. We suggest comparing on the cost per usable kilowatt-hour over the whole lifespan, not on the purchase price alone. No product is recommended in this guide.
- Tight budget, weekend use: an AGM battery may be enough.
- Daily or year-round use, weight to keep down: LiFePO4 is often preferred.
- In every case: a fuse, suitable cable and a compatible charge controller.
Sources
- Victron Energy, blog: lithium-ion (LFP) batteries versus AGM
- Victron Energy, Wiring Unlimited: DC wiring
Safety. This guide is for information only and replaces neither the manufacturer's instructions nor a professional's advice. For 230 V, high currents and any fixed installation, call a qualified professional.
Also worth reading
- Converted van: sizing your solar installation properly
- Vans and motorhomes: electrical safety and rules to know
- How Solanomad selects and presents products