The short answer
For a van with more than one small panel, or with a lithium battery, an MPPT controller is generally the choice of the sources we read. A PWM controller is only justified for a very small single-panel installation, when budget matters more than efficiency.
How each controller works
A charge controller sits between the panels and the battery. It prevents overcharging and adapts the voltage. Victron advises against connecting a panel directly to the battery.
A PWM controller pulls the panel voltage down to that of the battery: the voltage difference is lost. An MPPT (maximum power point tracking) controller makes the panel operate at its most efficient voltage and turns the surplus voltage into extra charging current. This principle is the one described in all the sources consulted.
What gain in practice?
Sources disagree. According to the retailer guides consulted, MPPT's gain over PWM is 20 to 30% in most conditions, sometimes up to 40% in cold or cloudy weather; one source cites 25 to 43%. Victron puts the gain at up to 30%.
These figures come mostly from manufacturers and retailers who sell MPPT: treat them as high estimates. The real gain depends on temperature, sunshine, the battery's state of charge and the panel voltage. It is smaller when the battery is almost full.
Comparison table
The lines below summarise the consensus of the sources, without precise figures where they disagree.
| Criterion | PWM | MPPT |
|---|---|---|
| Principle | pulls the panel down to the battery voltage | makes the panel work at its best voltage |
| Efficiency | part of the panel's power is lost | gain of 20 to 30% claimed (sources disagree) |
| Panels in series | limited | possible, up to the maximum input voltage |
| Cables on the panel side | higher current | higher voltage, lower current |
| Purchase price | lower | higher, modest gap according to one retailer |
| Typical case | a single small panel | installations from about 100 W, lithium |
A rule for choosing by power
Several guides put the limit at around 100 W of panels: below that, PWM may be enough; above it, MPPT pays for itself. This is a rule of thumb, not a standard.
Ask yourself three questions: how many watts of panels (see our guide on power), what battery chemistry (lithium calls for a suitable charging profile), and whether you want to wire the panels in series. Two yeses out of three: choose an MPPT.
- A single small panel, tight budget: a PWM may do.
- Several panels, lithium, a crowded roof: MPPT.
- If in doubt: MPPT, more flexible for future expansion.
Maximum input voltage: the point not to miss
An MPPT controller has a maximum input voltage (for example 75 V or 100 V depending on the model). The open-circuit voltage (Voc) of the panels added up in series must never exceed it. Victron gives the example of a 12 V panel of about 22 V Voc: three panels in series make about 66 V, which stays under a 75 V controller.
Open-circuit voltage rises when it is cold: keep a margin, and follow the indications in the controller's datasheet. Also check the controller's maximum charging current: it must cover the power of your panels.
An example and common questions
Imagine a 100 W panel whose operating voltage is higher than that of a 12 V battery. With a PWM, the panel is pulled down to the battery voltage, which loses part of its power. With an MPPT, the surplus voltage becomes current. If the gain were 20 to 30% as some sources claim, you would recover about 20 to 30 W more, or 100 to 150 Wh over a day with 5 hours of full sun.
This example is an arithmetic illustration of the range quoted by the sources, not a measurement. The real gain varies, and may be lower when the battery is almost full or the panels are hot.
Is an MPPT controller mandatory with lithium? It is not mandatory, but the controller must offer a charging profile suited to the chemistry, and several guides recommend MPPT for lithium.
Can you mix different panels? Panels with similar characteristics are easier to wire together. If the voltages or currents differ, efficiency falls: reread the manual, or ask an installer for advice.
What should you look for on a controller's datasheet? The maximum input voltage, the maximum charging current, the battery voltages accepted (12 V, 24 V), the charging profiles for your battery and the protections.
Installation and safety
The controller is set according to the battery (lead or lithium). According to Victron, a fuse is required between the panel array and the controller, in line with local rules. For cable sizes, see our guide on wiring. Have your installation checked by a professional; this guide does not recommend any product and does not guarantee compliance.
Sources
- Victron Energy, Wiring Unlimited: DC wiring
- The Green Watt: MPPT versus PWM, a comparison
- Tiny Build Electrics: solar charge controllers for campervans, MPPT versus PWM
Safety. This guide is for information only and replaces neither the manufacturer's instructions nor a professional's advice. For 230 V, high currents and any fixed installation, call a qualified professional.