The short answer
A rigid panel is fixed to the roof and produces while you drive, sleep or work, without you thinking about it. A folding panel is taken out, pointed at the sun and put away: it suits when the vehicle stays in the shade, when you have no roof space available or when you want to charge a power station away from the vehicle.
The choice therefore depends first on use, before price or power. The figures below come from manufacturers' datasheets and let you compare weight and bulk, two objective criteria.
The basic differences
A rigid panel is an aluminium frame with a glass front: solid, durable, designed to stay outside. A folding panel is a set of cells under a plastic film, often ETFE, joined by hinges: light, but made to be unfolded and stored. There are also flexible panels, very thin, which are glued or fixed onto a curved surface.
Two direct consequences: the rigid panel copes better with wind, rain and years of permanent exposure; the folding panel copes badly with being left outside all year round, unless the manufacturer says otherwise. Always look at the protection rating (IP) and the warranty stated on the datasheet.
Weight and bulk: datasheet figures
The table compares panels from both families. The watts per kilogram and per square metre are calculated by us from the power, weight and dimensions on the datasheet (unfolded area for folding panels). They are orders of magnitude, not guarantees.
| Panel (manufacturer datasheet) | Type | Power | Weight | W per kg | W per m² |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Victron BlueSolar 190 W | rigid | 190 W | 10.5 kg | about 18 | about 192 |
| Renogy 200 W ShadowFlux | rigid | 200 W | 10.81 kg | about 18.5 | about 207 |
| Offgridtec MONO 200 W | rigid | 200 W | 11.2 kg | about 18 | about 197 |
| Bluetti PV350 | folding | 350 W | 14.7 kg | about 24 | about 159 |
| Jackery SolarSaga 100 | folding | 100 W | 3.6 kg | about 28 | about 154 |
| EcoFlow Lightweight 160 W | folding | 160 W | 3.8 kg | about 42 | about 160 |
| ALLPOWERS SF100 | flexible | 100 W | 2.39 kg | about 42 | about 171 |
What the table shows
The rigid panels in our sample provide about 18 W per kilogram, the folding ones 24 to 42 W per kilogram. For the same power, a folding panel therefore weighs from 25% to more than half less, depending on the model. On the other hand, the rigid panel gets a little more power per square metre (about 190 to 210 W per m² against 150 to 170 for unfolded folding panels), which matters when roof space is tight.
The folding models in the table state a cell efficiency of 23 to 25% on their datasheets, but the efficiency of the whole panel is lower, which shows in the unfolded area. Always compare the stated power (in Wp, laboratory conditions) and not cell efficiency alone.
The 350 W folding panel in the table weighs a little more than a 200 W rigid one and unfolds over more than 2 m²: "folding" does not mean "light" or "small". It is mainly the folded shape that changes.
Fitting and orientation
A rigid panel lying flat on the roof stays fixed: it loses output when the sun is low or when the vehicle is badly oriented, but it works without any intervention from you. It is fitted with brackets or a suitable adhesive, and a cable must pass through the bodywork: plan a watertight gland.
A folding panel can be oriented. You can turn it towards the sun and place it away from the van's shadow, a real advantage: shade on a corner of a panel can sharply reduce its output. In return, you have to take it out, keep an eye on it, protect it from the wind and put it away.
Our sizing guide points out that on a van roof you count on about 60 to 75% of the stated power. A well-oriented folding panel can do better, but that takes your time, morning and evening.
Price and lifespan: what we do not quantify
We give no prices: they change often and vary between retailers. To compare, relate the price paid to the stated power and to the warranty on the datasheet, looking at the test conditions. A folding panel used every day wears mechanically at the hinges and cables; a rigid panel fixed to the roof wears mainly through exposure. None of the datasheets we read lets us say which will last longer in your use, and we do not claim to.
Use without a vehicle, off the roof
For a power station, hiking or camping without a vehicle, the folding panel is generally the only practical choice. Check two points on the datasheet: the maximum voltage accepted by the station's solar input and the connector type, because they differ from one brand to another.
For a lived-in van, the common combination is a rigid panel on the roof for the bulk of production, topped up with a folding one when the sun is low or the roof is in shade. See our guide on use without a vehicle for details.
- Choose rigid for daily production, durability and permanent fitting.
- Choose folding for portability, orientation and use away from the vehicle.
- Check the IP rating, the connectors and the maximum input voltage of the controller or station.
- Never exceed the maximum voltage and current given in the controller's manual.
Safety and wiring
A panel produces current as soon as it receives light, even when not connected. Do not connect it directly to a battery: a charge controller is needed (Victron expressly advises against it). If several panels are mounted in series, their voltages add up: check that the total stays below the controller's maximum voltage.
For cables, fuses and high currents, call a professional. This guide does not guarantee the compliance of any installation.
Sources
- Victron Energy, BlueSolar monocrystalline panels
- Renogy, 200 W ShadowFlux N-Type panel
- Offgridtec, MONO 200 W V2 panel
- Bluetti, PV350 datasheet
- Jackery, SolarSaga 100 datasheet
- EcoFlow, Lightweight 160 W portable panel
- ALLPOWERS, SF100 flexible panel
- Victron Energy, Wiring Unlimited: DC wiring
Safety. This guide is for information only and replaces neither the manufacturer's instructions nor a professional's advice. For 230 V, high currents and any fixed installation, call a qualified professional.